Virus Busters Home


The SULFNBK.EXE Virus Email Warning Is A Hoax, But....

by Bruce P. Burrell (bpb@umich.edu)
for the U-M Virus Busters (virus.busters@umich.edu)

Last significant update: 29 May, 2001

This information can be freely reproduced in any medium, as long as the information is unmodified.

Thanks to Keith Cedarleaf for first bringing this to our attention on 27 May, 2001.

Notes:

On to the analysis....

On 27 May, 2001, a correspondent asked us about the following:

Actually, no: you found a file of that name. Unfortunately, telling whether a file is infected with a virus by looking at its name is about as helpful as telling the doctor your name, and asking if you are sick.

The proper way to tell if a file is infected is to check it with a top quality, up-to-date virus scanner.

Actually, in this case, the file probably always has been there, and is not a virus. But perhaps not; more on this below.

Like "Roberta", "Joe" was probably misled as well. "Hey everyone! If you have a file named WIN.COM on your computer, it might be a virus !!!" Never mind the fact that a file of that name has been on every Windows system since forever....

The file was there because it's a part of Windows; the antivirus software didn't find a virus because it wasn't infected!

While it certainly is possible that there is a virus on someone's machine, it almost certainly isn't dormant. Viruses can't do that. Either they are active, or they are not; they can't hibernate.

Don't bother. Instead, follow our directions, and protect yourself against many nasties instead of just one.

Sigh. Another person who probably found an uninfected SULFNBK.EXE file....

Then how were YOU able to tell that it was a virus?

For the record, there is no such thing as an undetectable virus. Viruses have to make changes; once the change is found, the virus loses. Of course, some viruses may not have been detected YET, but as soon as an announcement of a real virus appears, rest assured that the antivirus companies already have a fix for it, or will in a matter of hours.

This is where things start to get tricky....

If it's a Win98 machine, it almost surely will find this file....

While most people won't need this file, and in most cases it won't be infected, let's suppose for the sake of argument that it IS infected. Removing this one file will not remove the virus. Only one infected file.

No.

Either you were safe before, or you were infected and you still are, albeit with one fewer infected file than before. But since you've just deleted the file, you can't disinfect it....

Ok, it's time to look at the facts:

  1. SULFNBK.EXE is a Win98 utility that backs up Long File Names (LFNBK, get it?) [Back in the Old Days of DOS, files were limited to names with 8 or fewer characters. This made for cryptic file names like, well, "SULFNBK" instead of easier to remember ones like "Netscape Navigator"]

  2. It turns out that there is a virus that:

    • looks in the Windows folder and its subdirectories for a file to infect

    • That file must be in "PE" (Portable Executable) format, and no larger than 132 KB.

      [SULFNBK.EXE, at 43 KB, is a file that meets these conditions -- one of 135 such files on my bare-bones Win98 system. Moreover, SULFNBK.EXE has an "odd" icon and name, which makes it more noticeable than some of those other 134 candidate files]

    • the virus mails out infected files.

  3. In fact, I've had plenty of reports of a file of this very name being sent out in email, infected by a virus.

That virus is W32/Magistr@MM -- a well known virus that people at U-M have been protected against since 14 March, 2001. That is over two months before this hoax appeared.

If those companies kept their antivirus software up to date, they'd have no problem with this particular thing.

Nonsense:

  1. So how do YOU, pray tell, know it is a virus?

  2. McAfee and Norton definitely do detect W32.Magistr@MM; many other products do as well.

Ok advice, I suppose -- but the message, however, is bogus: obviously, this file is SUPPOSED to be on Win98 systems. Besides, it would be a lot more helpful to say:

  1. NEVER ACCEPT UNSOLICITED ATTACHMENTS, even from those you know and trust.

  2. Get top quality antivirus software, install it, and USE it.

  3. Keep said software updated, preferably at least once a week.

  4. Avoid crappy emailers that allow active content, like the Microsoft Outlook variants. Otherwise, you WILL get bitten by junk like this.

That would *actually* protect against some 58,000 viruses, etc., instead of _maybe_ remove (but not protect against) ONE.

Bottom line:

   A. If you Practice Safe Hex, ignore the message.

   B. If you don't, *start* practicing it, NOW. But still ignore the message.

Please do not forward this -- or any other hoax -- to all your friends. Even ones with partial truths like this one.

Instead, you should reply to the sender -- and as far back up the email chain as you have energy -- informing the originators that this is a hoax. For this particular hoax, I suggest that you provide a pointer to this URL (http://www.umich.edu/~virus-busters/hoaxes/sulfnbk.html)
For virus or hoax info, please see our main page (http://www.umich.edu/~virus-busters/) or go to another reputable site, like The Urban Legends Reference Pages (leaving our site).

   -BPB

Virus Busters Home


Last updated: Wednesday, 02-Jan-2002 18:40:23 EST.
University of Michigan Virus Busters - virus.busters@umich.edu

visits to this page since 29 May, 2001 23:52 EST